|
Project
Proposal:
SIMSCOPE: Applications of
simulated microscopy and video editing
for the
development of multimedia
teaching tools in biological sciences
(First-year)
Participants:
UCR, UCD
Principal
Investigators:
Paul De Ley, UCR
Overview
of the Request
Multimedia teaching
tools are rapidly becoming an essential
component of higher education, and
show great promise in the teaching
of science courses dealing with microscopy
or microscopic subjects. A TLtC mini-grant
has allowed the construction of a
prototype CD and website, combining
Video Capture and Editing (VCE) with
hypertext files to teach nematode
biology and simulated microscopy to
undergraduates. The development of
these prototypes has generated great
interest among a much wider range
of faculty at UCR and UC Davis, who
wish to expand on these first prototypes
and develop similar tools for teaching
other science subjects.
Our combined group
of faculty has access to a great variety
of instructional materials and teaches
a wide range of courses in nematology,
biology and parasitology, often with
the aid of customized internet websites.
All of us are faced with similar problems
of teaching students how to use microscopes,
and most of us are not yet equipped
to obtain and edit video content.
We therefore request assistance from
TLtC to provide the resources to develop
skills and new tools with VCE, as
well as improved website tools. We
propose to greatly intensify instructional
synergy across two campuses and five
departments, by applying these tools
in a broad collaborative context focused
on the production and exchange of
VCE-based multimedia teaching tools
for microscopy.
Instructional problems:
a) Microscopy
and teaching
The microscope is
an essential tool in many science
courses, but the large size of introductory
classes typically precludes laboratory
experience with access to sufficient
numbers of microscopes. Even where
available, student microscopes paradoxically
provide the poorest level of resolution
to those who arguably need it most:
undergraduate students with no prior
experience. Slides with the clearest
specimens are usually reserved for
demonstration, because they are short-lived
in inexperienced hands. As a result,
students obtain a poor first impression
of practical microscopy, and many
are falsely led to conclude that they
lack the personal skills required.
Microscopy is also
instructionally difficult for more
subtle reasons. First, it requires
students to become familiar with all
the controls and parts of the microscope.
Second, the development of actual
observation skills can only begin
after students have familiarized themselves
thoroughly with operation of the microscope.
Observation is actually more difficult
than operation, as it relies on the
intuitive reconstruction of three-dimensional
mental images of the observed structures,
and this skill can only be acquired
through experience. Third, students
can read notes outside class hours,
but they cannot practice with a microscope,
and no online environment exists to
provide an appropriately similar context.
Fourth, traditional microscopy demonstrations
do not allow instructors to interact
with more than one student at a time.
These problems are compounded by biology
labs typically having 15 or more students
per section for a limited number of
lab hours, leaving minimal time for
extensive instructor-student interactions.
b) Introducing
video into the teaching environment:
Before VCE technology
can be used effectively in teaching,
it is essential that the teachers
themselves first learn how to use
it. Compared to still image editors
and webpage designers, most software
needed for video editing is not significantly
more difficult to learn. Nevertheless,
most faculty have not yet developed
video editing skills, because for
most of us reasons to incorporate
those into our research programs have
not yet been recognized, and hence
no extramural context for acquiring
video editors and learning how to
use them.
c) Acquiring
and exchanging video content for teaching
applications:
As with all IT resources,
a multimedia teaching tool can only
be effective if it has sufficient
information contents, and if these
are customized and organized to suit
the course subject. While many of
us teach a range of subjects and have
access to a wide selection of texts
and still images, it is as yet much
harder to find enough video clips
with the right subject matter. This
is especially true for more specialized
courses with limited enrollment, and
it is a major limitation even for
those among us who do already have
video editing equipment and experience.
Conversely, some faculty members are
already applying VCE as part of their
research and extension activities,
but they do not themselves teach the
courses that would benefit most from
this material. They also rarely have
the time and resources to edit and
adapt their video material to suit
the needs of other faculty who do
not yet have their own video capabilities.
Previous
results:
De Ley and Baldwin
have developed a first very limited
prototype of a VCE CD-ROM*
as a handout for NEM/XRC205 "Identification
of Plant Parasitic Nematodes",
taught last summer at UCR. Participants
were on average already experienced
in microscopy, but included some beginners,
and all were very enthusiastic about
the CD. With the support of a TLtC
mini-grant, De Ley, Baldwin and Nadler
have then developed a CD-ROM with
greatly expanded contents and functionality,
and introduced this as a study aid
into NEM/BIOL159 "Biology of
Nematodes", taught during spring
quarter 2002 at UCR. This CD addresses
mainly instructional problem (a) above
(teaching microscopy), more specifically
the problems of allowing students
to acquire observational skills, and
of improving knowledge transfer from
instructor to student (see appendix
A). It specifically utilizes the ability
of video clips to capture the action
of focusing through a semitransparent
microscopy specimen, and to mimic
this focusing action during playback
by allowing the viewer to move backwards
or forwards through each clip.
Proposed
innovations:
We propose to collaborate
intensively to introduce multimedia
teaching tools for microscopy subjects
in a wide range of courses at UCDavis
and UCR. More specifically, we request
funding to acquire software and training
for video editing and multimedia integration
applications, to allow for travel
and meetings facilitating production,
exchange and post-production of video
contents, to support student helpers
who will assist with the basic aspects
of VCE, and to support the cost of
post-production services by multimedia
specialists at UC Davis and UCR. Hard
copies of the created teaching tools
will be distributed on CD rather than
on DVD, because DVD hardware is not
yet sufficiently widely distributed
to ensure that all students will be
able to access DVD copies in 2003.
Our long-term objectives
are to disseminate video editing skills
and facilitate development of microscopy-based
teaching tools across all UC campuses
for as wide a range of courses as
possible. To maintain focus and manageability
for 2002-2003, we will limit our efforts
specifically to the following major
themes:
a) Development
of the front end and optical algorithms
for virtual microscopy:
The prototype CD produced with support
of the TLtC mini-grant only mimics
the focusing and observation aspects
of microscopy. In order to improve
the speed and quality of student training
in microscope operation, we propose
to develop an interactive image of
a microscope that will simulate all
the basic controls and operations
of a student microscope. This "virtual
student microscope" will be made
available to lower-division undergraduate
students on a CD and via a dedicated
website.
Dr. Cardullo and
Dr. Carter both have access to advanced
microscopy equipment, including confocal
systems. Dr. Cardullo has already
developed a set of advanced microscopy
exercises, in the context of his annual
Analytical and Quantitative Light
Microscopy course at the Marine Biological
Laboratories in Woods Hole. Dr. Carter
has experience in developing optical
performance calculators for confocal
microscopy. Their expertise and resources
will be combined with those of IET
Mediaworks to develop a CD with customized
exercises and simulation modules for
interference contrast and confocal
microscopy, aimed at upper-division
undergraduates.
It should be noted
that several "virtual microscopes"
have been produced for other reasons
(e.g. http://met.open.ac.uk/vms/vms.html,
http://micro.magnet.fsu.edu/primer/virtual/virtual.html,
http://www.cs.umd.edu/projects/hpsl/ResearchAreas/vm.htm).
Although several of these sites are
excellent resources, they are restricted
in various ways, for example simulated
operations are not operated via an
interactive front end, the range of
simulations is limited to certain
techniques only, full access is only
possible at a significant charge,
etc. Most importantly, none of these
sites is aimed at training undergraduates
in the use of a basic light microscope
by means of an interactive image that
actually represents a generic microscope.
To be implemented
by: Dr. Richard Cardullo (Biology,
UCR), Dr. David Carter (Botany &
Plant Sciences, UCR), Dr. Paul De
Ley (Nematology, UCR), Dr. Harry Matthews
(IET Mediaworks, UCDavis), Dr. Becky
Westerdahl (Nematology, UCDavis)
Virtual student microscope to be
used in: BIOL005B Introduction
to Organismal Biology (approximate
annual enrollment or AAE 145), ABI50B
Animal Biology (UCDavis, AAE 30),
BIS10V Virtual General Biology (UCDavis,
AAE 150).
Advanced microscopy exercises CD
to be used in the following courses
at UCR: BIOL109 Laboratory in
Cell and Molecular Biology (organized
in alternate years, approximate enrollment
15), BIOL113 Advanced Cell Biology:
Membranes, Organelles, and the Cytoskeleton
(AAE 30), BIOL114 Advanced Cell Biology:
Cellular Reproduction and Signaling
(AAE 30), BPSC135 Plant Cell Biology
(AAE 20), BPSC/BIOL138 Morphology
of Vascular Plants (AAE 25).
b) Creation of
a "Virtual Arabidopsis"
CD and website:
Arabidopsis thaliana is an
essential model for a wide range of
genetic, physiological and mutational
studies in plants, and directly relevant
to a wide range of botanical courses.
We propose to develop a multimedia
teaching tool that would represent
the wild type plant as well as selected
mutants, to show how the mutant phenotypes
differ. An image map of each "virtual
weed" would provide links to
a gallery of images and video clips
of pollen, flowers, seeds, leaves,
roots etc. at different magnifications.
To be implemented
by: Dr. David Carter, Dr. Natasha
Raikhel, Dr. Zhenbiao Yang (all Botany
& Plant Sciences, UCR).
To be used in the following courses
at UCR: BPSC/BIOL104 Foundations of
Plant Biology (AAE 80-100), BPSC/BIOL132
Plant Anatomy (AAE 10), BPSC135 Plant
Cell Biology (AAE 20), BPSC/BIOL138
Morphology of Vascular Plants (AAE
25).
c) Creation of
a "Virtual Lab for Cell Biology
and Neuroscience" CD and presentation:
The equipment/software requested in
this proposal would be used to digitize
images of histological microscopy
sections and to create movies to complement
the lab exercises for NRSC169. Students
would receive a disk at the beginning
of the quarter, allowing them to study
these data before and after class,
rather than being able to view these
data only during the labs and review
sessions. The CD would also contain
quizzes for each lab section, which
would be used to keep them up to date
with material and to allow them to
check their understanding of each
segment of the course as it unfolds.
In addition, the CD would include
video material on human development.
One of the most important aspects
of teaching developmental anatomy
is being able to show students information
in three dimensions, the best solution
for which are 3D movies. Dr. Talbot
already has a number of videos that
could be included, and others will
be made or created with the requested
equipment. The CD will also serve
a valuable purpose as a resource that
the students can use at any time in
the future when they need to consult
or review the information in the course.
To be implemented
by: Dr. Prudence Talbot (Cell
biology and Neuroscience, UCR)
To be used in the following course
at UCR: NRSC169 Human Embryology
(AAE 55)
d) Creation of
multimedia teaching tools for courses
in Nematology, Parasitology and General
Biology:
Because of the many parallels in subject
matter between courses taught by faculty
of the nematology departments at UCR
and UCDavis, all collaborators from
both faculties will produce, exchange
and adapt video contents to maximal
advantage. The planned interactions
and targeted courses are summarized
in the table in Appendix B. In brief,
we intend to produce teaching tools
for a total of 17 courses, including
15 CD's with virtual slides and/or
virtual labs, 11 websites for courses
taught partially or fully online,
and Microsoft Powerpoint presentations
with embedded video for 4 courses.
Some collaborators
will have more specific roles in the
exchange process. Microscopes in the
laboratories of Dr. De Ley, Dr. Baldwin
and Dr. Nadler will be available as
general facilities for obtaining VCE
microscopy clips, to be used by those
collaborators who do not have all
the equipment required in their own
laboratory. Dr. Baldwin and Dr. Nadler
are curators of two of the world's
largest collections of preserved nematodes
and will continue to produce "virtual
specimens" of important nematode
species. Dr. Becker and Dr. Ploeg
(UC Organized Research and Extension
appointments) have no teaching appointments,
but both are willing to provide video
contents pertaining to plant nematodes
and their control. Dr Ploeg and Dr.
Westerdahl already have a range of
edited and unedited video clips, which
will be made available to the relevant
collaborators for post-production
and integration into course materials.
Dr. Becker, Dr. Westerdahl, Dr. Caswell-Chen
and Dr. Roberts are conducting or
will conduct research in the quarantine
facilities of the respective departments,
and will provide video microscopy
clips using VCE equipment provided
by matching funds from the respective
campuses (see below).
Other
activities:
a) Training of
faculty and student helpers:
In order to successfully
develop the tools listed above, we
will initially organize a two-day
joint training session in September
2002 for all faculty and student helpers
involved, to be held at the Digital
Production Lab (UCR) with joint presenters
from IET Mediaworks (UCDavis) and
Computing & Communications (UCR).
Participants will be instructed in
the use of video editing software
(Premiere, Final Cut Pro) and web
authoring software (Flash, Dreamweaver).
b) Planning and
exchange meetings:
Following immediately
on the training sessions at UCR for
training, all participating faculty
will meet to summarize availability
of existing video material, to compare
mutual needs for new material, and
to finalize production plans accordingly.
A second two-day joint meeting will
be held in March 2003, to demonstrate
prototypes and final versions of the
created tools, to review availability
of and demand for additional video
material, to visit IET Mediaworks
in order to finalize post-production
of more complex material, and to coordinate
completion efforts on those tools
that still require it.
c) Virtual access
to quarantine facilities and organisms:
UCR's Department
of Nematology currently has a functioning
Nematode Quarantine Facility, and
UCDavis is in the process of constructing
a new Contained Research Facility.
Both of these are or will be the setting
for research on invasive organisms
that are highly destructive to agricultural
crops and are therefore of immediate
relevance to Nematology and Parasitology
courses. Because of the strict regulations
on access to and removal of material
from these facilities, it is at present
not possible to incorporate live recordings
of the behavior of quarantine species,
nor is it practical to illustrate
quarantine methodology in its actual
settings. We propose to equip both
facilities with VCE equipment that
will be used to produce video clips
and still images, which can then be
sent out via ethernet with no risk
of accidental release of the quarantine
organisms. This equipment will be
financed with matching funds provided
by UCR and UCDavis.
d) File storage
and exchange:
Password-protected
server space will be made available
at no cost by Computing & Communications
(UCR), to allow efficient file exchange
between collaborators by FTP.
Future
plans:
If awarded, the
one-year Full-implementation Grant
will not only provide us with the
means to create the products and skills
listed above, but it will also allow
us to prepare for further expansion
of our efforts. Specifically, we intend
to seek extramural funds from potential
sources such as FIPSE, USAID Institutional
Partnerships Program, ECA Internet
Access and Training Program, etc.
We also intend to request a second
year of Full-implementation Grant
funding from TLtC, with the specific
purposes of:
- Extending our collaboration
to other departments and UC campuses
- Integrating the
"virtual student microscope"
front end with the advanced microscopy
simulation tools, to produce a "virtual
differential interference contrast
microscope" and a "virtual
confocal microscope"
- Updating and expansion
of all tools created for CD distribution
in 2002-2003, and conversion to DVD
format (we expect DVD technology to
be readily accessible to all students
by 2004 or 2005). This will apply
for all relevant courses, and will
require a training component in the
use of DVD authoring software.
Specific
Aims
The aims of our
current planning project are:
(1) To produce a CD and website
for use in the following courses:
NEM/BIOL159 Biology of Nematodes
(UCR), NEM/XRC205 Identification of
Plant Parasitic Nematodes (UCR) and
NEM 110 Introduction to Nematology
(UCDavis). We aimed to include 20
specimens from at least 10 species
on the CD, and another 20 specimens
from at least 10 species in the website.
As originally planned,
all specimens to be included would
be from preserved material kept in
the nematode collections at UCR and
UCDavis. However, during demonstrations
of live material in the initial two
labs for NEM/BIOL159 it became abundantly
clear that the students would benefit
from having video clips of live nematodes
(especially behavioral and size mutants)
and other microscopic organisms. We
therefore adjusted our aims and deferred
some of the editing of preserved material,
in order to include more video clips
of live organisms.
We are currently
improving on the beta version of our
CD on the basis of evaluations by
the students of NEM/BIOL159 (see below),
by adding further hyperlinks to the
various files, and in order to adapt
the contents to meet the slightly
different emphases given in NEM110
at UCDavis. This improved version
will also be integrated with the online
teaching tools for NEM/BIOL159 already
implemented in UCR's Blackboard system
by Dr. Leo Schouest and collaborators.
Due to previously
unforeseen scheduling conflicts, NEM/XRC205
will not be organized in the summer
of 2002, but will be resumed in the
summer of 2003. For this year, we
have instead used the NEM/BIOL159
CD in two different ways to reach
audiences similar to the potential
students for NEM/XRC205: we have demonstrated
the CD during the 34th California
Nematology Workshop (De Ley, March
26-28, see below), and we have incorporated
it in the teaching of a three-day
training course at Mira Costa College,
Oceanside (Baldwin, April 9-11, 2002).
(2) To develop
plans for extensive collaboration
involving many more collaborators
and biological disciplines. As
outlined in our application, and discussed
in more detail below, we have been
successful in generating widespread
interest in VCE-derived teaching tools
for microscopy-related courses.
Planning
Outcomes
Creation
of a microscopy CD for NEM/BIOL159:
We constructed
a beta version of a "virtual
microscopy lab" on CD for the
students of NEM/BIOL159 (four copies
are submitted to the UCR TLtC office
along with this application). The
CD in question contains 7 complete
virtual nematode specimens belonging
to 6 different species, as well as
video recordings of eight different
mutants of the genetic model organism
Caenorhabditis elegans, and video
recordings of three other examples
of microscopic soil invertebrates.
The video clips are integrated with
different sets of web pages, respectively
containing diagrams of nematode anatomy
(adapted from the diagrams used in
the classes), and image maps providing
an overview of a complete nematode.
Other web pages provide a glossary
of technical terms, and a brief description
of the purpose of the CD: teaching
students how to use focus as an integral
part of the act of observation through
the microscope.
Completion of the
CD took longer than expected, especially
in terms of constructing image maps
and embedding these in hypertext pages,
to link them to each other as well
as to the video files. These last
steps in the process were mainly implemented
with the HTML editing features in
Microsoft Word and in Netscape Composer,
which are clearly not very efficient
tools for the purposes of embedding
image maps and video clips.
Introduction
of the NEM/BIOL159 CD to the students:
The CD was completed
just in time for inclusion in the
last class of NEM/BIOL159. 30 upper-division
undergraduate students were provided
with a copy of the CD, and given a
demonstration of how to access its
text, image and video files using
an internet browser like Internet
Explorer and Netscape Communicator.
The students were clearly interested
in the demonstration, and surprised
by the use of video clips as simulations
of focusing action. They were also
given a short questionnaire on the
accessibility and usefulness of the
CD. Results of the 7 returned and
forms were as follows:
1. Do you think
this CD is useful for understanding
and studying this course?
Not at all: 0
Not very: 0 Somewhat: 3 Very: 4
2. Did you experience
technical problems accessing the files?
No: 5 Yes: 2
(one additional student reported
that she could not access the files
at all and therefore did not return
the questionnaire)
3. Did you find
text errors or broken links?
No: 6 Yes: 1
4. Is the information
logically presented and structured?
Not at all: 0
Not very: 0 Somewhat: 1 Very: 6
5. Feel free to
give us any other comments or suggestions!
Only two responses:
"This would
have been very useful at the beginning
of the course. This CD was very
helpful in showing what the nematode
structures look like. Good job!"
"...(detailed
description of a technical problem
accessing the video files, and short
list of more information from the
course that should be included,
followed by:)..Overall, it should
be a very helpful tool in viewing
nematodes & seeing structures
that are hard to see in the lab!"
In terms of number
of responses, we conclude that enthusiasm
among students was not exceptionally
high or low, as could be expected
from the late introduction of the
CD into the class. We did not insist
that all students return the questionnaire
"or else...", as this would
have compromised the sincerity of
their responses. Most students of
the responding did not experience
significant technical problems, but
accessibility can clearly still be
improved, and the minimum hard- and
software requirements need to be stipulated
more clearly.
Meeting at UCR:
Dr. Steve Nadler
and staff member Ashleigh Smythe visited
UCR for three days (March 6-8) to
bring selected material and use it
for a hands-on workshop on video capture
and editing, using the system in the
De Ley lab. We also commenced the
planning process for the full implementation
grant. The following was our agenda
for the workshop:
Wednesday March
6th
* noon - Arrival
at Ontario Airport, lunch.
* afternoon - hands-on of the various
steps of capture and basic editing
from slides and live material using
both FinalCut on Macintosh and Premiere
on a PC platform.
Thursday March 7th
* morning - advanced
editing: adding titles, scale bars,
arrows and labels to clips.
* noon - lunch
* 1.30-3.30 pm - Brainstorming session
with Dr. Leo Schouest of Computing
& Communications.
* remainder of the afternoon - construction
of image maps to link all clips
Friday March 8th
* morning - continued
construction of image maps to link
all clips
* noon - lunch
* afternoon - construction of the
web pages that organize access to
the clips, integration of draft webpages
and sets of clips.
* 5 pm - departure
The agenda was adhered
to on March 6 and 7, but on March
8th it became again obvious that the
final steps of web page construction
and integration require more efficient
web design software. The brainstorming
session with Dr. Schouest was extremely
productive, e.g. in defining the virtual
student microscope front end as an
objective for the implementation grant,
and in identifying better software
solutions for the web design and page
integration steps.
Meeting at UC
Davis:
Dr. James Baldwin
and Dr. Paul De Ley visited UC Davis
with staff members Dr. Irma T. De
Ley and Dr. Manuel Mundo for three
days (March 26-28) to recruit collaborators,
to settle on the main themes of the
full implementation grant, to explore
opportunities at the DANR nematology
workshop for developing video-based
nematode identification teaching tools,
and to present the NEM/BIOL159 CD
to a mixed audience of students, faculty
and farm advisors at the 34th California
Nematology Workshop. Our agenda was
as follows:
Tuesday March 26th
* noon - arrival
at Sacramento airport, lunch
* afternoon - meeting in Dr. Nadler's
office, followed by DANR Nematology
workgroup meeting (explore opportunities/needs
for lesion nematode identification
tools)
Wednesday March
27th
* morning - 34th
California Nematology Workshop (talk
to potential collaborators)
* noon - lunch
* afternoon - 34th California Nematology
Workshop (demonstration of NEM/BIOL159
CD)
Thursday March 28th
* morning - planning
meeting in Dr. Nadler's office (8.30-9.30
am), meetings with Dr. Caswell and
Dr. Ferris (9.30-10.30 am), visit
to IET Mediaworks and brainstorming
session with Dr. Harry Matthews and
collaborators (10.45 am - noon)
* noon - lunch
* 2 pm - departure
No commitment for
support could be obtained through
DANR (Department of Agricultural and
Natural Resources) for identification
tools for lesion nematodes species,
because some of the workgroup members
questioned the difficulty of identifying
those nematodes. In other respects,
this meeting was very helpful in raising
interest among potential collaborators
from both UCDavis and UCR. The brainstorming
session at IET Mediaworks allowed
us to identify and integrate the relevance
of their expertise and services, especially
with regards to post-production of
video files, and the creation of an
interactive front end of a virtual
student microscope.
Significance
Although we are
still improving on the teaching tools
produced with the support of the TLtC
planning project, we already consider
it to have been instrumental and highly
successful, in enabling us to demonstrate
some of the many potential applications
of VCE microscopy. This has allowed
us to bring together a large number
of collaborators for a full implementation
project. It has also highlighted that
it is not sufficient to generate skills
and tools for video editing, but that
we also need to improve our software
capabilities and knowledge with respect
to web design.
Faculty on both
campuses are greatly interested in
possibilities for incorporating video
material into their teaching of microscopy-related
courses. This integration will be
highly beneficial to students in a
range of situations, such as theoretical
courses without labs, courses relating
to expensive equipment and advanced
techniques that cannot be incorporated
into truly hands-on labs, or labs
that would otherwise require a 1:1
instructor/student ratio for maximal
transfer of knowledge.
However, there is
at present a definite barrier for
UC faculty to learn how to use video
software and hardware, both in terms
of its limited relevance to research
projects and funding, and in terms
of allowing faculty members to acquire
the necessary level of (basic) video
editing and (more advanced) web design
skills. We therefore consider it essential
that our full implementation proposal
not only focuses on the production
of teaching tools for the students,
but also emphasizes training and software
availability for the instructors.
*
The contents of this CD are accessible
at http://faculty.ucr.edu/~pdeley/vCenema1/home.html
|