Students have always needed guidance when learning how to conduct scholarly
research. But, according to faculty, never has the need been as urgent as it is
now. The reason -- the Internet. Instead of going to the library to conduct
research, today's students are tempted to go to popular search engines like
Google without understanding their limitations [ see related article ]
or knowing how to evaluate the results that they generate.
The UC campuses
have adopted many different approaches to help students acquire the skills
necessary to perform scholarly research in today's information-rich environment.
Several campuses offer for-credit courses that teach students about conducting
research, and librarians often visit classrooms to provide instruction on how to
use library resources for a particular subject area.
UC Berkeley has taken an
innovative approach by creating a fellowship program in which librarians work
with faculty to integrate research assignments into undergraduate courses. Known
as the Mellon Library/Faculty Fellowship for Undergraduate Research, the
program's goals include building "undergraduate knowledge of information
resources" and enhancing "student research and information competencies." Funded
for four years by a grant from the Andrew W. Mellon Foundation, the program has
an emphasis on lower division courses with the goal of introducing research
skills early on so that students can develop and apply them throughout their
academic careers.
"A lot of Berkeley's undergraduates go on to graduate
school so we want to prepare them to be good scholars," says Elizabeth Dupuis,
project director of the Mellon program. "We want the fellows to walk away
feeling confident that they redesigned a course introducing some kind of
research for their students beyond a traditional research paper."
Fifteen
faculty fellows attend a two-week summer institute and are teamed with
"implementation teams" assigned to work with them throughout the semester in
redesigning their courses and research assignments. The implementation teams are
made up of representatives from various academic service units including the
Library, GSI Teaching and Resource Center, Student Learning Center, and
Educational Technology Services.
The Mellon program targets high impact
courses, such as introductory or "gateway" courses to "ensure that all students
have this introduction to conducting research at logical times in their academic
career," says Dupuis.
Michelle Douskey, who teaches Chemistry 1A, had already
tried integrating a research project into her course before she became a Mellon
fellow in 2004. Although experimental projects are common in introductory
chemistry courses, library-based research projects are not.
Douskey says
that integrating such a project into the huge course -- 1300 students in 43
sections -- was daunting, and that several colleagues told her it could not be
done. She says she was only able to pull it off because of the help she received
from her Mellon implementation team.
"I was trying to figure out a way to
engage the students in discovering knowledge for themselves rather than me being
a purveyor of knowledge that they would somehow absorb," says Douskey. "I wanted
to create an experience in which the students had to pull concepts together at
the end of the semester and not just study for the final. I wanted a deep
understanding of the relevant chemistry of the chosen topic."
She used
student peer review to minimize the labor required of herself and the graduate
student instructors, as well as to help students learn by teaching. The students
prepared posters about their research and presented them during their discussion
sections. In addition, every student was required to critique two other
posters.
Overall, the project was a success, says Douskey.
"I'm seeing a
big impact in my course and with myself," says Douskey. "Because of the nature
of these large enrollment courses, we have a chance to make a real impact on the
university, which is exciting."
Charis Thompson, a professor in Rhetoric and
Gender & Women's Studies, and Greg Niemeyer, a professor in Art Practice, became
Mellon fellows to help them develop a new interdisciplinary course called the
"Foundations of American Cyber-Cultures." Not only was the content of the course
about technology, but the instructors also used digital tools in almost every
aspect, such as to "hand out" assignments, provide feedback, and do grading.
Students were required to present their research in the format of web pages and
submit all of their work electronically.
But the instructors were not
interested in only technological ways of accessing and presenting information.
They devoted one class period to a walking tour of all the campus's "sites of
knowledge production," such as the library and media commons, and a librarian
provided in-class instruction on research methodologies and contributed content
to the course, says Thompson.
"It was great fun to do something that was not
just content interdisciplinary but also technically interdisciplinary," says
Thompson. "We emphasized that every form of knowledge has a medium and every
time has a technology and the web is ours today."