Since 2000, students in five classes at UC Berkeley from computer science and
other departments have used Tablet PCs on an experimental basis. A team of
faculty and graduate students is experimenting with the tablets to discover if
they can enhance learning by increasing student engagement and facilitating
live discussions in small groups during lectures.
The project is called Livenotes, which involves wirelessly networked Tablet PCs
loaded with custom-built software that allows the notes that one team member
writes to be seen in real-time by the other team members belonging to the same
group. Students can exchange notes with group members using a shared white
board and annotate the instructor's PowerPoint slides during an ongoing
lecture.
"The motivation behind Livenotes is to facilitate small group learning in the
large lecture class," says Matthew Kam, a graduate student involved in the
project. "We wanted students to help one other learn the material. There have
been over 375 studies since 1898 which show that cooperative small-group
learning is more effective than individualistic or competitive group learning."
Kam and the research team, which includes John Canny, a professor in the
Computer Science division, found that the process of using tablets for
cooperative note-taking had benefits, as well as distractions, for students.
They found that when compared to individual note-taking, the collaborative
process enabled students to compose more comprehensive lecture notes, engage in
a greater degree of higher-order thinking and pay greater attention in class.
They also found that the resulting set of notes reflected a higher degree of
internalization of the lecture material.
The Livenotes team observed that undergraduate students were not used to
discussing the lecture material with one another, as compared to graduate
students who had previously used Livenotes. This made it a challenge to deploy
Livenotes in undergraduate classes. "When using Livenotes, undergraduates tend
to focus on taking down everything that the instructor says in case it might be
on the exam. We had to coach them to engage in small-group discussions by
pausing lectures a couple of times, during which we gave students some
questions to discuss with their neighbors," says Kam. Some students also found
it distracting to focus on both the small-group dialogue and the lecture at the
same time, even though they became better at coping over time.
The research team continues to experiment with, and make improvements to, the
Livenotes system, both in undergraduate and graduate courses. They are adding
features that enable more interaction between students and instructors, such as
students being able to tell the lecturer anonymously and in real-time if he or
she is going too fast, as well as the instructor being able to pose questions
electronically to students during the lecture.